Nine top picks — ranked by authentic reviews, current price, new roof installation, and high quality.
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. How we make money.
All picks, best reviews first.
Features patented SureNail reinforcement for superb grip and blow-off resistance, making it an installer and homeowner favorite.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$51.76–$150
Sorted by overall review score — not by sponsorship.
A top-tier architectural shingle offering industry-leading weight, durability, and vibrant color blending for full roof replacements.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$45.32–$160
Delivers the rich, rustic charm of authentic hand-split cedar shakes without the rot, insect susceptibility, or fire hazards of wood.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$69.94–$600
Offers custom-cut artisan styling reminiscent of classic slate roofs at a fraction of the cost of real stone.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$32–$260
North America's most popular architectural shingle, known for seamless installation and an industry-leading wind warranty.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$49–$145
Provides the timeless, elegant look of natural slate with modern asphalt performance and high wind resistance for luxury homes.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Best price
$742.50
Engineered with sustainable polymer-modified asphalt to provide superior flexibility, impact resistance, and long-term granule retention.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$46.67–$155
A luxury asphalt shingle engineered to replicate natural quarried slate with multi-layered depth and unmatched weight.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$93.25–$320
A high-end composite slate tile engineered for maximum impact and fire ratings without requiring structural roof reinforcement.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$55–$550
All picks, cheapest first.
Offers custom-cut artisan styling reminiscent of classic slate roofs at a fraction of the cost of real stone.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$32–$260
Sorted by price — not by sponsorship.
A top-tier architectural shingle offering industry-leading weight, durability, and vibrant color blending for full roof replacements.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$45.32–$160
Engineered with sustainable polymer-modified asphalt to provide superior flexibility, impact resistance, and long-term granule retention.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$46.67–$155
North America's most popular architectural shingle, known for seamless installation and an industry-leading wind warranty.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$49–$145
Features patented SureNail reinforcement for superb grip and blow-off resistance, making it an installer and homeowner favorite.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$51.76–$150
A high-end composite slate tile engineered for maximum impact and fire ratings without requiring structural roof reinforcement.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$55–$550
Delivers the rich, rustic charm of authentic hand-split cedar shakes without the rot, insect susceptibility, or fire hazards of wood.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$69.94–$600
A luxury asphalt shingle engineered to replicate natural quarried slate with multi-layered depth and unmatched weight.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Price range
$93.25–$320
Provides the timeless, elegant look of natural slate with modern asphalt performance and high wind resistance for luxury homes.
Matches best rated · high quality · new roof installation
Best price
$742.50
Everything you need to know before choosing.
Owens Corning Duration Shingles (scores 8.6/10). Features patented SureNail reinforcement for superb grip and blow-off resistance, making it an installer and homeowner favorite.
Owens Corning Duration Shingles is the top pick for new roof installation.
Owens Corning Duration Shingles is the top pick for high quality.
Owens Corning Duration Shingles is the top pick for best rated.
