
Vince
Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater
+2.3 vs this product
We'll find live prices
BC523-BK0001
Before you buyWe found 5 better-rated alternativesRated up to 8.8/10 by real buyers, vs 6.5/10 for this one.See alternativesCommunity verdict
Buyers frequently praise the sweater for its soft, non-itchy feel, comfortable warmth, and flattering cut, with many women opting for men's sizing for a cozy, oversized fit. However, long-term knit enthusiasts and repeat customers report issues with pilling and declining quality compared to earlier iterations.
11
reviews collected
11
authentic reviews
0
sponsored removed
0
flagged as AI
Points that came up again and again across the authentic reviews.
Better-rated alternatives
J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater scored below our bar (6.5/10). These match what it's for and score better with real buyers.
Matched on: Sweaters · cashmere turtleneck sweater · cashmere material · turtleneck style

Vince
+2.3 vs this product
We'll find live prices
Nordstrom
+1.8 vs this product
Shoppers would pick it for its cashmere material and turtleneck style.
We'll find live prices
Banana Republic
+1.3 vs this product
$19.99
Theory
+1.3 vs this product
$365
Club Monaco
+0.9 vs this product
$69.99
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. How we make money.
J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater
2 sellers · prices updated daily
| Seller | Condition | Offer | Price | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| J.Crew | new | Codes aren't guaranteed | $198 | Visit seller |
| PoshmarkCheapest | new | Codes aren't guaranteed | $158$128 19% off | Visit seller |
A concise summary of what verified buyers of J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater consistently praise — and what they don’t.
Direct organic buyer opinions about J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater, filtered for spam and ads.
I’m really happy with the quality and fit!
Quality of course is perfect and the softness is a 5 star.
I recently purchased a cashmere sweater from J Crew and it’s pilling badly.
I would rank J. Crew’s current cashmere near the very bottom
Everything you need to know about J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater before buying.
Reviewers highlight: Soft non-itchy feel; Flattering relaxed fit; Warm without extra layers.
Common criticisms include: Excessive pilling; Questionable long-term durability; Variable knit thickness.
The J.Crew Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater scores 6.5/10 (mixed sentiment), based on reviews from Reddit, YouTube, Google Shopping, and social media.