Community verdict
The appliance receives mixed initial feedback but leans negative overall due to durability issues. Buyers praise its fast ice cycles, quiet operation, and attractive compact design when it works properly. However, multiple reviewers report that the machine stops freezing ice or breaks down within five to eighteen months, with several criticizing the costly warranty return process.
6,208
reviews collected
6,207
authentic reviews
1
sponsored removed
0
flagged as AI
Points that came up again and again across the authentic reviews.
A concise summary of what verified buyers of Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker consistently praise — and what they don’t.
Direct organic buyer opinions about Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, filtered for spam and ads.
Quick ice production within six minutes. Compact and space-saving design ideal for countertops.
This machine is very quiet and operates flawlessly
It worked really good with no problems for year then ice cubes got smaller and were vase shaped with tall thin neck.
I have bought two of these exact same units now and both quit working in less than a year of use.
Everything you need to know about Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker before buying.
Reviewers highlight: Quick ice production; Compact countertop size; Quiet operation.
Common criticisms include: Poor long-term reliability; Frustrating warranty process; Defective units out of box.
The Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker scores 4.2/10 (negative sentiment), based on reviews from Reddit, YouTube, Google Shopping, and social media.